PRIVATE ONE-ON-ONE TUITION · ONLINE WORLDWIDE

Cost Curves for First-Year Micro at USyd and UNSW: A Sydney Microeconomics Tutor’s Guide to the Short Run and the Long Run

Microeconomics · Macroeconomics · Econometrics & Finance

Cost curves look like four lines on a graph until a question asks you to choose between them. If you are in first-year microeconomics at the University of Sydney, UNSW, Macquarie or UTS, this cost curves lesson from a Sydney microeconomics tutor starts with one firm’s real decision and builds every curve you need to settle it: fixed, variable, average and marginal cost in the short run, then the long-run curve that ties them together.

A roaster’s accountant raises an alarm

A specialty coffee roaster leases a medium-sized roasting machine. Its fixed cost, the lease and the overheads that come with it, is 16 thousand AUD a week, whatever it roasts. Its variable cost, mainly labour and gas, is 0.25q² thousand AUD a week, where q is tonnes of roasted coffee. This week it roasts 12 tonnes.

The accountant runs the numbers. Total cost is 16 + 0.25 × 144 = 52 thousand AUD, which is 4.333 thousand per tonne. At 8 tonnes the same machine would cost only 4 thousand per tonne. “This machine is running past its cheapest point,” the memo says. “Lease the large machine.”

The large machine has a fixed cost of 50 and a variable cost of 0.125q². Is the accountant right? Hold the question. Answering it properly takes the whole family of cost curves, short run and long run.

Fixed, variable, average, marginal: the short-run family

In the short run the machine is fixed. Only labour and gas can change. (Leave the cost of the beans out; it would add a constant cost per tonne and change nothing below.) That splits total cost TC into a fixed part FC, paid even at zero output, and a variable part VC that grows with output. Divide each by q and you get the averages.

Curve Definition Medium machine
Average fixed cost, AFC FC/q 16/q
Average variable cost, AVC VC/q 0.25q
Average total cost, ATC TC/q = AFC + AVC 16/q + 0.25q
Marginal cost, MC extra cost of one more unit 0.5q

AFC always falls, because the same lease is spread over more coffee. AVC rises here from the first tonne. With the machine fixed, each extra tonne needs more labour than the last as the roastery gets crowded. That is diminishing marginal returns to the variable input, and it is the reason short-run marginal and average costs eventually climb.

Marginal cost needs one line of care. Strictly, it is the rate at which total cost rises with output. If you know calculus, it is the derivative of TC, so 0.5q here. If you do not, read it as the extra cost of the last tonne. The two agree closely when one tonne is small relative to output.

Short-run cost curves, medium machine 4 8 12 16 20 2 4 6 8 10 cost per tonne (thousand AUD) output, tonnes a week MC ATC AVC AFC minimum ATC
Figure 1. The medium machine’s short-run curves. ATC is U-shaped because falling AFC and rising AVC pull against each other. MC crosses ATC at its lowest point: 4 thousand AUD a tonne at 8 tonnes.

At 8 tonnes, AFC = 2 and AVC = 2, so ATC = 4. Marginal cost is also 0.5 × 8 = 4. That is no coincidence.

Why marginal cost cuts average cost at its lowest point

Think of your average mark in a course. If the next assignment scores below your average, the average falls. If it scores above, the average rises. Cost works the same way. The marginal tonne is the next assignment, and the average responds to it.

At 4 tonnes, MC = 2 and ATC = 16/4 + 1 = 5. The marginal tonne is cheaper than the average, so the average is still falling. At 12 tonnes, MC = 6 and ATC = 4.333. The marginal tonne is dearer, so the average is rising. The turning point must be where the two are equal, and that is 8 tonnes. In symbols, the slope of ATC is (MC − ATC)/q, so ATC is flat exactly where MC = ATC.

Many textbooks draw AVC as a U as well, because early workers make each other more productive before crowding sets in. MC then cuts AVC at its minimum by the same argument. In this roastery AVC rises from the start, so it is lowest as output shrinks toward zero, where it meets MC.

Changing the machine: the long run

In the long run every input can change, including the machine. The roaster can choose a small machine (fixed cost 6, variable cost 1.5q²), the medium one, or the large one. Each machine has its own ATC curve. The small one bottoms out at 2 tonnes and 6 thousand per tonne. The medium one bottoms out at 8 tonnes and 4. The large one bottoms out at 20 tonnes and 5.

The long-run average cost curve, LRAC, answers one question at each output: what is the cheapest way to produce this much if you may pick any machine? So it is the lowest of the three ATC curves at every q, their lower envelope. The curves cross at 2.83 tonnes (small against medium) and 16.49 tonnes (medium against large).

Long-run average cost as an envelope 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 2 4 6 8 10 average cost per tonne (thousand AUD) output, tonnes a week small medium large LRAC MES 12 t
Figure 2. Three machines and the long-run envelope. Below 2.83 tonnes the small machine is cheapest, from 2.83 to 16.49 the medium one, above that the large one. LRAC bottoms out at 8 tonnes, the minimum efficient scale.

Now go back to the memo. At 12 tonnes, the medium machine costs 4.333 thousand per tonne, 52 thousand a week. The large machine would cost 50/12 + 0.125 × 12 = 5.667 per tonne, 68 thousand a week. Keep the medium machine. The accountant compared the medium machine at 12 tonnes with the same machine at 8 tonnes. The real comparison is between machines at 12 tonnes, because 12 tonnes is what the roaster sells. The large machine only pays above 16.49 tonnes, and only if output is expected to stay there.

The shape of LRAC carries its own vocabulary. While LRAC falls, the firm enjoys economies of scale: bigger operations are cheaper per unit. The output where LRAC is lowest, 8 tonnes and 4 thousand per tonne here, is the minimum efficient scale. Beyond it, LRAC rises and the firm faces diseconomies of scale. These are long-run ideas about changing every input together. Do not confuse them with diminishing marginal returns, which is a short-run idea about adding one input to a fixed machine. With only three machines the two blur at the edges: between 8 and 16.49 tonnes LRAC rises partly because the medium machine is being pushed. The cleanest evidence of scale is the machines’ own minimum costs, which fall from 6 to 4 and then rise to 5.

When orders double

Suppose a café chain signs on and orders jump to 24 tonnes a week. In the short run the medium machine is all the roaster has. Average cost climbs to 16/24 + 0.25 × 24 = 6.667 per tonne, total cost to 160 a week, and the marginal tonne costs 12.

Once the large machine can be leased, the same 24 tonnes cost 50/24 + 0.125 × 24 = 5.083 per tonne, 122 a week, with a marginal cost of only 6. The short run is the long run with an extra constraint attached, so it can never be cheaper. Here the constraint costs 38 thousand AUD a week. That gap is exactly why the firm wants to change the machine when demand shifts for good.

The lessons that build on this one start from these curves. Market structures from perfect competition to monopoly and monopoly pricing with its deadweight loss both take the cost curves as given and ask how much to produce and, under monopoly, what price to charge.

Viner’s draftsman and the smooth envelope

With only three machines, LRAC is scalloped. Let the roaster choose from a continuous range of machine sizes and the scallops smooth out. The envelope then touches each short-run ATC curve at a single point. Here is the catch. Except at the minimum efficient scale, that point is not the bottom of the short-run curve.

Left of the minimum efficient scale, LRAC is falling, so the tangency sits on the falling part of the short-run curve. A slightly larger machine run below its own minimum beats a smaller machine run flat out. Right of it, the tangency sits on the rising part. The memo’s 12 tonnes is a three-machine version of the same thing: the cheapest way to make it uses the medium machine past its own minimum.

The economist Jacob Viner slipped on exactly this point. For his 1931 paper “Cost Curves and Supply Curves” he wanted the long-run curve to pass through the lowest point of every short-run curve while never lying above any of them. His draftsman, the mathematician Y. K. Wong, objected that this was impossible when the long-run curve is U-shaped. Viner wrote in a footnote that he could not follow the objection, and conceded the point only years later. If a careful theorist could slip here, it is worth one slow pass of your own. If you later meet cost minimisation as an optimisation problem, the Lagrange method is how the cheapest input mix behind each point of LRAC is found.

Three exercises on costs

Exercise 1. The small machine has total cost 6 + 1.5q². Find AFC, AVC, ATC and MC at 1, 2 and 4 tonnes. Where does MC equal ATC?

Answer. At 1 tonne: 6, 1.5, 7.5 and 3. At 2 tonnes: 3, 3, 6 and 6. At 4 tonnes: 1.5, 6, 7.5 and 12. MC = ATC at 2 tonnes, the bottom of the small machine’s ATC.

Exercise 2. Using all three machines, which is cheapest at 3, 10 and 18 tonnes a week, and what is LRAC there?

Answer. At 3 tonnes the medium machine, at 6.083 per tonne (the small one would cost 6.5). At 10 tonnes the medium machine, at 4.1 (the large one would cost 6.25). At 18 tonnes the large machine, at 5.028 (the medium one would cost 5.389).

Exercise 3. Orders jump from 8 to 24 tonnes. Switching to the large machine costs a one-off 300 thousand AUD for installation and training, and the medium machine’s lease can be handed back at no cost. Ignoring everything else, how long must the higher orders last to make the switch worthwhile?

Answer. At 24 tonnes the medium machine costs 160 a week and the large one 122, a saving of 38 a week. The switch pays if the orders last longer than 300/38 = 7.9 weeks.

Questions students ask about cost curves

Is the long run a fixed length of time? No. It is however long it takes to change every input. For a roaster leasing a machine that might be a few months. For a steelworks it might be years.

Why doesn’t the firm simply produce at minimum ATC? Minimum ATC is the cheapest cost per unit, not the most profitable output. How much to produce depends on price and demand as well as cost, which is what the market-structure pages work out.

What causes diseconomies of scale? The usual suspects are coordination and management costs as an organisation grows. In this lesson they are simply built into the large machine’s numbers, and the evidence on how strong they are differs a lot across industries.

If cost curves are where your first-year micro marks are slipping, at the University of Sydney, UNSW, Macquarie or UTS, one-on-one economics tutoring for USyd and UNSW students can go through your own tutorial questions with the same envelope picture: which curve the question is really about, and which comparison it is really asking for. See how sessions run.

Book a micro tutor in Sydney before the cost questions pile up

Send the tutorial sheet or the past exam that is causing trouble, and you will be matched with a PhD tutor for one-on-one sessions online. A micro tutor in Sydney time zones can fit around your lectures and tutorials. Use the booking form or the WhatsApp button at the top of the page.

Get Started

See the #1 economics
mentoring platform in action